diff options
| author | Dennis Fink | 2026-10-23 20:24:21 +0200 |
|---|---|---|
| committer | Dennis Fink | 2026-10-23 20:24:21 +0200 |
| commit | b87b08e8ebacf9521f3aa507d76761031798e2d3 (patch) | |
| tree | a7cb757e60351616e08395d085e86ea35afa0d03 /content/blog/the-sharing-web/contents.lr | |
| parent | 128fa0f837f5c7f5b3e2fcb8e3bb1ada579531e0 (diff) | |
| download | dennisfink.me-b87b08e8ebacf9521f3aa507d76761031798e2d3.tar.gz dennisfink.me-b87b08e8ebacf9521f3aa507d76761031798e2d3.zip | |
Publish The Sharing Web
Diffstat (limited to '')
| -rw-r--r-- | content/blog/the-sharing-web/contents.lr | 230 |
1 files changed, 230 insertions, 0 deletions
diff --git a/content/blog/the-sharing-web/contents.lr b/content/blog/the-sharing-web/contents.lr new file mode 100644 index 0000000..d54f616 --- /dev/null +++ b/content/blog/the-sharing-web/contents.lr @@ -0,0 +1,230 @@ +title: The Sharing Web +--- +publication_date: 2026-10-23 +--- +body: + +#### markdown #### +text: + +The [World Wide Web](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/World_Wide_Web) was built to +share information. From the beginning, it was designed as a network of +decentralised servers and clients communicating with each other. However, over +the past 25 years, it seems to me that the web has become much more +centralised. + +Initially, I also embraced the new, exciting and fascinating world of social +media. However, the more time I spent on it, the less I enjoyed using it. I +never posted much on social media. Over the years, I have used many of them and have seen +them come and go. I still remember when +[Diaspora](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Diaspora_%28social_network%29) was +launched, and the hacker scene — of which I was a part at the time — thought it +would be revolutionary. In my opinion, it didn't really take root until +[Mastodon](https://joinmastodon.org/) joined the field, and even then, it only +really took off after the +[Twitter](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/X_%28social_network%29) meltdown. + +# Do you really need to comment? + +One of the things that bothers me most about the modern web is that it makes +everyone feel like they have to publish their opinion on everything. I remember +listening to a [Big Think interview with Stephen +Fry](https://bigthink.com/videos/how-oscar-wilde-helped-stephen-fry-confront-his-sexuality/), +in which he also touched on this issue: + +<blockquote cite="https://bigthink.com/videos/how-oscar-wilde-helped-stephen-fry-confront-his-sexuality/"> + <p> + It’s such a pity and that’s one of the reasons I love the online world is + that although that exists in abundance you can choose absolutely which part + of the online world you want to live in. You can make your own kingdom in + that sense, so things like Twitter or whatever I’m sure there are all kinds + of Twitter you know clusters of people who have politics that I would find + horrific and really just views that I would preposterous and impertinent, + but I just don’t have to follow them and I can block them and I will never + know they exist and that’s glorious. + </p> + <p> + And similarly as long as you don’t lower your eyes when reading a blog, as + long as you don’t go down to the comment section where the trolls lurk, + where the viciousness is because that’s… I mean there really is just + suppurating, boiling seas of acid where if you just so much as dip a toe + you’ve lost your limbs you know, just vileness abounding. + </p> +</blockquote> + +Source: Stephen Fry, <a +href="https://bigthink.com/videos/how-oscar-wilde-helped-stephen-fry-confront-his-sexuality/"><cite>How +Oscar Wilde Helped Stephen Fry Confront His Sexuality</cite></a>, <time +datetime="2009-12-08">8 December 2009</time>, ~13:30 + +In his later blog post, ["No +Comment..."](https://www.stephenfry.com/2010/05/no-comment/), he writes: + +<blockquote cite="https://www.stephenfry.com/2010/05/no-comment/"> + <p> + I don’t know about you, but my eyes are already trained only to read the + top half of a web page these days. Rather as a Victorian would not look + below the waist, I do not let my eyes have even a second’s contact with the + revolting Have Your Say or Comments section of a BBC site, a YouTube page + or any blog or tech forum. The lower half of web pages is very like the + lower half of the body — full of all kinds of noxious evil smelling poison. + </p> +</blockquote> + +Source: Stephen Fry, <a +href="https://stephenfry.com/2010/05/no-comment/"><cite>No +comment...</cite></a>, <time datetime="2010-05-28">28 May 2010</time> + +This influenced me so much that, since then, I have tried not to read the +comment sections on websites. However, sometimes I still find myself reading +them. This is also one of the reasons why I don't have any comment +functionality on my blog. There are, of course, some technical reasons why I do +not offer it, but the biggest reason is that I do not want the legal +responsibility that comes with hosting content created by others. + +This doesn't mean that I don't want people to respond to what I write. On the +contrary, [I still believe that the web is for +sharing](/blog/2026/06/back-to-blogging/). And this might make me seem +hypocritical after the paragraphs above, but let me explain my reasons. + +My main goal is to be in control of what I read and consume. I want +people to publish their own stories and opinions, to link to interesting +content and to respond when they have something to add. What I don't want is +for all of those things to be pushed into the same space where everybody is +expected to read and participate in the resulting conversation. I want +independent spaces for people where they are in control of their inputs and +outputs. + +So, how can people share their stories or opinions with me while I remain in +control of what I read? + +# The Independent Web + +In recent years, and especially since the beginning of this year, I have +noticed a resurgence in the movement to build an [independent +web](https://indieweb.org/). The idea behind it is that people own their +content by hosting and publishing it themselves. Recently, Adam Newbold +[blogged about how anyone can do it and how inexpensive it can +be](https://www.neatnik.net/hardcore-indieweb). For those who are not +technically inclined, I can recommend this [blog +post](https://brennan.day/a-beginners-guide-to-the-indieweb-for-writers-who-dont-code-but-maybe-want-to-a-little/) +by [Brennan Kenneth Brown](https://brennan.day/). + +One fundamental problem with the independent web is discoverability. How can we +find other people on the independent web? Services like +[Bubbles](https://bubbles.town/), [Ye Olde Blogroll](https://blogroll.org/) and +[Kagi Small Web](https://kagi.com/smallweb/) are definitely good starting +points, but they still feel somewhat centralised. I would like to use more +decentralised methods. + +In 2017, the W3C published the [Webmention](https://www.w3.org/TR/webmention/) +protocol. They describe it as: + +<blockquote cite="https://www.w3.org/TR/webmention/#abstract-p-1"> + <p> + Webmention is a simple way to notify any URL when you mention it on your + site. From the receiver's perspective, it's a way to request notifications + when other sites mention it. + </p> +</blockquote> + +Source: W3C, <a +href="https://www.w3.org/TR/webmention/#abstract-p-1"><cite>Webmention</cite></a>, +<time datetime="2017-01-12">12 January 2017</time> + +Even though Webmention is not directly meant to solve the discoverability +problem, it can still help make the people and websites that form the +independent web more visible. When one site mentions another and sends a +Webmention, it creates a connection between the two. Following these +connections can lead readers from one independent website to another and, in +that way, help them discover people and sites they might otherwise never have +encountered. + +I wrote my own implementation of this protocol, which you can find +[here](https://git.dennisfink.me/webmentions-ssg/) (more about open source +projects later). My blog also supports it, and you can send me webmentions. I +have not yet implemented the extensions [Vouch](https://indieweb.org/Vouch) or +[Private-Webmention](https://indieweb.org/Private-Webmention). As I will not +support comments on my blog, I will probably never implement the extension +[Salmention](https://indieweb.org/Salmention). + +Recently, there was some discussion on the independent web about the privacy +implications of Webmention, which you can read about +[here](https://kevquirk.com/privacy-and-webmentions), +[here](https://vhbelvadi.com/webmention-copyright-privacy) and +[here](https://manuelmoreale.com/thoughts/thinking-about-privacy-and-webmentions). +My implementation does not import or display any content from external sites. +The only thing it does, following the spec, when receiving a new webmention is +to check whether the source really links to my blog. It does not modify my blog +post to include a reference back to the source. If you find one, that +means I added it manually. + +Webmention is probably the most technical way to make your reply known to me, +but it is an open protocol in which everyone can participate. In addition, I +believe that one should have different ways to achieve the same goal and not be +forced to use one specific method. + +While reading about how to provide reply options for my readers, I came across +the blog post ["Please let me interact with your blog +post!"](https://michaelharley.net/posts/2026/08/22/please-let-me-interact-with-your-blog-post/) +by [Michael Harley](https://michaelharley.net/), where he also proposes email +as a viable option. That post is why I implemented this option as well, but to reduce +possible spam I used some of these [email address obfuscation +methods](https://spencermortensen.com/articles/email-obfuscation/). + +Reflecting on this, I came to a similar conclusion for open source software. + +# Maintaining Open Source Software + +Years ago, when I came into contact with the local hacker scene, I was +introduced by a friend to the concept of free and open source software. At that +time, I had already taken my first steps into programming, and while learning a +new language, I began to publish my little tools as open source. I also +contributed, although rarely, to some projects. But there was a thought that +lingered in the back of my mind for a long time. + +We have seen maintainer burnout in the past and probably will see more in the +future. I have also experienced hostile behaviour from a maintainer in response +to a feature request. All this makes me mindful of my own well-being in this +matter. + +The same principles that influence how I handle comments on my blog also +influence how I publish my software. I want to share my source code, but +sharing it does not mean that I want to open another channel through which +anyone can demand my attention. Open source does not mean open access to the +maintainer. + +This led to making my software not available anymore on centralised hosting +platforms, but hosting it [myself](https://git.dennisfink.me). This +means that contributions to my software are now deliberately gated. There is +no issue tracker anymore; there are no feature requests and there are no pull +requests. If you want to contribute to my software, you can send a patch via +email. I may read your email, I may reply to you, and I may apply the patch or +not. + +# Sharing on my own terms + +In the end, I still believe that the web is for sharing. I want to share what I +write and the software I create, and I want other people to be able to respond +or contribute. But sharing something does not mean giving up control over my +own space or making my time and attention freely available to everyone. + +Whether it is through Webmention, email or Mastodon, I prefer methods that let +people reach me without placing me under an obligation to read, reply to or act +on everything I receive. I can decide what I consume, what I respond to and +what I accept. + +For me, that is what an independent web should offer: the freedom to share, but +also the freedom to choose how we interact with each other. +--- +description: Why I believe in an independent web where sharing ideas and software doesn't mean giving up control over my time, attention, or online space. +--- +tags: + +blogging +personal-web +digital-independence +webmention +open-source +--- +category: essays |
